When you’re in the market for a new car, it’s easy to be drawn to models with similar price points, but the decision often comes down to more than just cost. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at two popular options—the MG Windsor EV and the Tata Curvv Petrol—both priced around ₹9.99 lakh. However, they bring very different offerings to the table. Let’s break down the comparison in terms of price, technical specs, engine, design, build, and more.
Table of Contents
1. Introduction
The MG Windsor EV and the Tata Curvv Petrol are both exciting options for car buyers, especially given their nearly identical starting price. However, the MG Windsor, being an electric vehicle, offers a more futuristic take on mobility, while the Tata Curvv Petrol sticks to a more traditional internal combustion engine (ICE) setup. Let’s see how these two cars stack up in different categories.
2. Price Comparison of MG Windsor EV vs Tata Curvv Petrol
While both cars are priced at ₹9.99 lakh, their value proposition differs significantly.
- MG Windsor EV: As an electric vehicle, the MG Windsor benefits from government subsidies, lower running costs, and tax incentives, which could make it a better long-term investment for those concerned about day-to-day expenses.
- Tata Curvv Petrol: Tata’s offering comes at the same price but caters to drivers who prefer petrol-powered vehicles, providing an easier refueling option and a more familiar driving experience.
3. Technical Specifications
MG Windsor EV:
- Battery: 50 kWh lithium-ion
- Power: 150 HP
- Torque: 350 Nm
- Range: 300 km on a single charge
Tata Curvv Petrol:
- Engine: 1.2-litre Turbocharged Petrol
- Power: 130 HP
- Torque: 200 Nm
- Mileage: 15 km/l
At a glance, the MG Windsor EV outshines the Tata Curvv Petrol in terms of torque and power, but the range (and the challenge of charging infrastructure) might be a deciding factor for some.
4. Engine and Powertrain
Here’s where the difference is stark.
- MG Windsor EV: Fully electric, it offers instant torque and smoother acceleration thanks to its electric motor. However, charging might be a challenge for some buyers, depending on where they live and their access to charging stations.
- Tata Curvv Petrol: Powered by a petrol engine, this car provides reliable performance. It’s easier to refuel compared to finding charging stations for the Windsor, making it a more convenient option for long-distance drivers.
5. Performance Analysis
In terms of on-road performance:
- The MG Windsor EV provides a silent, vibration-free ride thanks to its electric motor, but the added weight from the battery slightly reduces its agility.
- The Tata Curvv Petrol, on the other hand, delivers a more traditional driving experience, with the revving engine and the petrol-fueled power coming through on open roads.
6. Design and Aesthetics
Both cars bring a modern flair to their designs.
- MG Windsor EV: It has a futuristic, sleek exterior that showcases the brand’s commitment to cutting-edge technology. The aerodynamic lines also help in boosting its electric range.
- Tata Curvv Petrol: The Tata Curvv boasts a more rugged, sporty appearance with sharp lines and a bold grille that make it stand out as a petrol-powered SUV.
7. Build Quality and Durability
When it comes to build quality:
- MG Windsor EV feels robust with its use of high-strength steel, contributing to its overall safety. It’s built for durability, especially with its reinforced battery pack that adds an extra layer of safety.
- Tata Curvv Petrol also doesn’t disappoint in this category, boasting Tata’s reputation for solid construction. However, petrol engines typically require more maintenance in the long term compared to the near maintenance-free electric motor in the Windsor.
8. Fuel Efficiency and Range
The MG Windsor EV provides a range of 300 km on a single charge, making it an efficient option for urban commuting.
The Tata Curvv Petrol, while offering an acceptable mileage of 15 km/l, does not match the cost-effectiveness of an EV, especially considering the rising fuel prices.
9. Environmental Impact
Electric vehicles like the MG Windsor EV have a clear environmental edge. With zero emissions, it’s the greener choice between the two.
The Tata Curvv Petrol inevitably contributes to emissions, though it complies with the latest BS6 regulations, making it a relatively cleaner petrol engine.
10. Features and Technology
Both cars are loaded with tech, but the MG Windsor takes it a step further.
- MG Windsor EV: Comes with a large touchscreen display, connected car features, and advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS). It’s a tech-heavy vehicle, catering to the digital age.
- Tata Curvv Petrol: Features a touchscreen infotainment system, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and a rearview camera, though it lacks the advanced tech of the MG Windsor EV.
11. Comfort and Space
In terms of comfort:
- MG Windsor EV: Spacious interiors, leather seats, and ample legroom make it an inviting car for long journeys.
- Tata Curvv Petrol: Also offers a comfortable cabin with a slightly sportier seating position, though the rear seat legroom might feel a bit tight for taller passengers.
12. Safety Features
Both cars score well in safety, with airbags, ABS, and electronic stability programs, but the MG Windsor EV edges out with its additional driver assistance features.
13. Maintenance and Running Costs
Maintenance is where the MG Windsor EV shines. With fewer moving parts, the Windsor’s electric motor doesn’t require the regular servicing that the Tata Curvv Petrol’s engine needs. In terms of running costs, the Windsor is far cheaper to operate, as electricity is more affordable than petrol.
14. Resale Value
Electric vehicles tend to have a better resale value due to their lower maintenance costs, and the MG Windsor EV is no exception. However, as the EV market continues to evolve, the depreciation curve might slow.
The Tata Curvv Petrol, while reliable, may face more depreciation, especially as the market trends towards greener options. [1]
Conclusion
Both the MG Windsor EV and the Tata Curvv Petrol offer strong propositions at ₹9.99 lakh, but they appeal to different types of buyers. The Windsor is perfect for those looking towards the future of mobility with lower running costs and a greener footprint, while the Curvv Petrol is a reliable, conventional choice for drivers who aren’t ready to make the switch to electric. Your choice will ultimately depend on your driving habits, lifestyle, and long-term goals.
FAQs
1. Which car has better mileage: MG Windsor EV or Tata Curvv Petrol?
The MG Windsor EV offers a range of 300 km per charge, while the Tata Curvv Petrol gives about 15 km/l.
2. Which car is more environmentally friendly?
The MG Windsor EV, being an electric vehicle, produces zero emissions and is the more environmentally friendly option.
3. What is the resale value of the MG Windsor EV?
As the EV market grows, the MG Windsor EV is expected to have a strong resale value due to lower maintenance costs and increased demand for electric vehicles.
4. Which car has more advanced tech features?
The MG Windsor EV offers more advanced technology with features like ADAS and connected car services, whereas the Tata Curvv Petrol offers standard tech features like infotainment systems.
5. How does the maintenance of an electric vehicle compare to a petrol car?
Electric vehicles like the MG Windsor EV typically have lower maintenance costs due to fewer moving parts compared to petrol cars like the Tata Curvv.
